Monday, October 6, 2008

Sekula & Batchen

On the Invention of Photographic Meaning by Allan Sekula

Ectoplasm: Photography in the Digital Age by Geoffrey Batchen

1 comment:

Thomas J. Gustainis said...

Hannah Wiessner:

Week 4

Ectoplasm by Batchen
The vast majority of this reading is based around the idea that photography is a dying art form. Soon the medium itself will be an unnecessary means of expression or information provider. Just like its predecessor (painting and drawing) it has been replaced by computerized images. “unable to spot the “fake” from the “real”, viewers will increasingly discard their faith in the photograph’s ability to deliver objective truth.” This entertains the idea that because of a photograph’s mysterious or illusional appearance, people’s inherent need for concrete truth and facts, will lose interest in it’s distinguished expressive format. Batchen also states that with the combination of it’s epistemological failure, and it’s being replaced by computers and other more advanced forms of technology, our present society wouldn’t find a need for photography any longer, aesthetically or for daily knowledge. This to me is a very scary concept. Although I am not sure whether I agree or disagree with this potential reality. I understand how it could fail as a sufficient source of information, but at the same time I don’t think because a picture could possibly be misleading, that our desire for stimulating imagery would decrease.
Another point of focus was how photography has always been associated with death since it’s birth. Many people believe that each time your photo is taken, it steals a part of your soul, and after so many photos are taken, very little of the person you remains. This is a theory that has been discussed for ages, and resulted in multiple cultures finding photography an evil medium since it’s origin. By bringing up this topic of discussion, is Batchen implying that due to this belief, that certain cultures would find the discontinuiation of photography a positive thing? Do these societies find other art mediums (such as visual illustration, painting, and even computer graphics ) more acceptable?